Punk Rock An Oral History - John Robb
I really need to keep track of where I first hear about a book or record, cuz I can't remember at all where I first heard of this 2006 tome, but I just discovered it very recently and was able to find it at a reasonable price, so grabbed it. It seems like it should actually be called British Punk Rock, as it is completely Brit-centric, but since that's where Robb is from, that makes sense, I suppose. He has quite a history in music, apparently, although I have never heard or even heard of him or his band, the Membranes - guess I should see what they're about while I'm at it...
In any case, this is another book in the Please Kill Me mode (which pre-dates this one by 10 years or so, and had an almost identical subtitle) with snippets of interviews with early participants compiled together in a chronological order to make a coherent story. Of course, most of the early punks grew up in the late 50's and 60's, making them exposed to the wildness that was early rock'n'roll and most everyone has pretty stellar taste in music (although I never got the reggae/punk connection, which seems to be a British thing, overall), which is why they created such cool sounds themselves!
Funnily - to me, anyway - Robb puts footnotes on glaringly obvious things but not on some very British things and people that Americans like me have no idea about. But, I guess if I really cared, I could look them up, couldn't I? (I just did and discovered that someone was talking about a soccer player - I never would have guessed, even in context there was no clue.) Also, early on I noticed a blatant error in the footnotes, so take it all with a barrel of salt...
Most of the people interviewed actually come off very well, somewhat modest in their accomplishments and acknowledging their influences - except for Lydon, of course, who, as always, comes off pretty insufferable. As we all know, the New York scene is where everything started and those bands - especially the Ramones - were the blueprint for the London scene, although Robb's narrative makes it sound like punk existed only in England, even while he talks about the importance of bands like the Ramones (and others), as when he calls Damned, Damned, Damned the first punk album! Clearly, he means the first British punk album, as the New York scene had already released a number of LPs. Laughable since he already talked about how much the Ramones first several albums (among others) influenced everyone in Britain.
As an aside - Robb mentions Eddie Cochran a few times but spells it “Cochrane” - no idea why but kind of annoying! Things like this and other bits I've already mentioned makes Robb a bit unreliable, but, as I said, the main characters interviewed - with a few exceptions - do their best to set the record straight and not over-sensationalize their (legit) accomplishments. Hilariously, Robb also mentions that what he calls "punk's second wave" (although probably at least 3rd by then, in reality) were the "true punk bands fulfilling punk's original prophecy". Certainly up for interpretation, although he seems to be equating hard core (I suppose I should say "Oi bands", since it's Britain) with punk rock, which is not the same in my mind, so there ya go...
So, as time goes on Robb gets into bands that I have never heard and have not been interested in (although maybe I should check some out and see what I've been missing) so the book starts to flag for me and is nowhere near as exciting as the early days. But, I'm sure that others will find this period more interesting than the original days, if that's where their interest lies. Having said that, there are some interesting groups in the post-punk/goth/mod/whatever scenes, so there's always something to bring back interest. He ends things in 1984 - a decent place considering he's not trying to create a history of punk rock!
Naturally, this was a big endeavor and Robb should be heralded for that, despite some minor quibbles. Certainly a good read for fans of real punk rock!